What Is Dunkelflaute and How Does It Affect European Power Markets?

Dunkelflaute, often translated from German as “dark lull,” refers to a sustained period with little electricity generation from both wind and solar resources. These episodes are particularly significant during the darker winter months, when limited daylight reduces solar generation and cold temperatures can increase electricity and natural gas demand. In European power markets, reduced renewable output can raise residual load, the electricity demand that must be met after variable renewable generation. The impact on power prices and gas-fired generation depends on demand, dispatchable capacity, storage, imports, and fuel costs.

For energy meteorologists on power and natural gas trading desks, the central forecast questions are the timing, duration, geographic extent, and uncertainty of low-renewable conditions. To show how forecast data can be used to assess that risk, World Climate Service built an example German Dunkelflaute Risk Index (DRI) and applied it to ensemble forecasts from its Point-in-Time Weather Forecast API. In the example index’s record from January 1, 2010 to October 1, 2026, 44 runs lasted at least five consecutive days below the seasonally adjusted 20th-percentile threshold, while nine lasted at least five days below the 10th-percentile threshold. These are historical findings from an illustrative index, not power-price forecasts or estimates of future event likelihood.

How Does Dunkelflaute Affect European Power and Natural Gas Markets?

Dunkelflaute reduces the contribution of wind and solar generation to electricity supply. If demand is unchanged, lower variable renewable output raises residual load, which must be met by other generation sources, storage discharge, demand response, or electricity imports. The available response varies by bidding zone, transmission constraints, generation outages, and fuel and carbon prices.

In Germany and neighboring European markets, a widespread low-wind period may occur across several connected bidding zones. This can limit how much additional wind-generated electricity is available for export, although imports may still provide material support from other generation technologies and regions. Market coupling transmits supply and demand conditions between interconnected markets, subject to transmission capacity.

Does Dunkelflaute Always Increase Wholesale Electricity Prices?

No. Lower wind and solar output can increase wholesale electricity prices when additional or more expensive supply is required, but the response is not automatic. Demand, thermal and hydro availability, storage operations, gas and coal prices, carbon costs, and cross-border flows all matter. Day-ahead and intraday prices respond to information available at different points before delivery.

An emerging Dunkelflaute signal is therefore an input to supply-demand analysis, not a standalone power-price forecast. For a distinct real-world example, the Bundesnetzagentur and Bundeskartellamt investigated November and December 2024 periods of very low wind and solar generation. They reported day-ahead prices reaching €936/MWh and found that electricity imports helped avoid even higher prices. Those 2024 market conditions should not be attributed to the separate December 2022 example below.

How Can Dunkelflaute Affect European Natural Gas Demand?

Natural gas demand for electricity generation may increase when gas-fired plants are dispatched to offset part of a wind and solar generation shortfall. If the episode coincides with colder weather, heating demand can increase at the same time. These effects depend on temperatures, the power-generation mix, fuel economics, plant availability, and the flexibility of alternative supplies.

For European gas desks, the operational question is whether low renewable generation creates an incremental call on gas-fired generation, and for how long. Storage withdrawals, pipeline flows, LNG sendout, and dispatch must be assessed separately. An Oxford Institute for Energy Studies analysis examined the gas-demand variability associated with January and November 2024 Dunkelflaute episodes across the EU-27 and UK. A DRI reading does not predict TTF or any other natural gas price directly.

What Meteorological Conditions Lead to Dunkelflaute?

Periods of weak wind can be associated with persistent large-scale circulation patterns, including some slow-moving high-pressure systems. Low solar generation can reflect short winter daylight, cloud cover, fog, or a combination of these factors. High pressure does not necessarily imply low solar radiation, so the wind and solar signals should be evaluated independently and then together.

The geographic extent also matters. A circulation pattern may suppress wind generation over Germany while producing different conditions farther north, west, or south. Weather regimes can provide context for these spatial patterns and their persistence, but a regime classification alone does not establish that Dunkelflaute will occur.

Request a World Climate Service free trial

What Did the December 2022 Dunkelflaute Show About German Wind and Solar Generation?

In the example DRI’s historical analysis, December 8 to 17, 2022, was the longest consecutive episode below the date-specific 10th-percentile threshold during the January 1, 2010 to October 1, 2026 record. Over those 10 days, combined German wind and solar generation was approximately 3,054 GWh below its estimated seasonal normal.

Generation source Seasonal normal (GWh) Actual (GWh) Actual as % of normal
Wind 4,586 1,568 34%
Solar 238 203 85%
Wind and solar 4,824 1,770 37%

WCS calculations using ENTSO-E actual generation and Ember installed capacity. The seasonal normal is estimated from installed capacity multiplied by the normal capacity factor for each date. Displayed figures follow the source analysis; component totals are rounded.

The combined shortfall of 3,054 GWh is equivalent to an average generation difference of about 12.7 GW over the 10-day period. Wind accounted for approximately 99% of the calculated shortfall. During this episode, capacity-weighted 100 m wind speed averaged 58% of normal, while wind generation averaged 34% of normal. Wind turbine power output varies nonlinearly with wind speed, which helps explain the difference between these percentages.

December 10 had the lowest wind-generation day in the 10-day period, averaging 3.3 GW against a seasonal normal of 19.0 GW. These figures describe generation relative to a climatological baseline. They do not establish which specific plants, imports, or demand adjustments supplied the difference.

How Widespread Was the December 2022 Low-Wind Episode?

Wind generation was also below normal from December 8 to 17, 2022, in several other European markets. WCS calculated 28% of normal in the Netherlands, 51% in France, 53% in Denmark, and 55% in Poland. Conditions varied farther away, including 74% of normal in Sweden, 71% to 103% across Norwegian zones, 102% in Spain, and 124% in Italy.

These differences illustrate why energy meteorologists should assess geographic coverage rather than infer conditions in neighboring markets from Germany alone. Simultaneous generation shortfalls can affect available cross-border supply, but actual imports depend on demand, conventional generation, interconnection capacity, and prices in the connected markets.

How Can a Dunkelflaute Risk Index Be Calculated?

The example Dunkelflaute Risk Index combines German wind-power-capacity-weighted 100 m wind speed and solar-power-capacity-weighted shortwave radiation into a daily meteorological index. Each input is expressed as a percent of its date-specific normal, then weighted by its estimated normal seasonal contribution to wind-plus-solar generation. The index is designed to identify anomalously low meteorological conditions, not to reproduce metered generation.

How Are Wind Speed and Solar Radiation Normalized?

Wind (% of normal) = 100 x V / Vn

Solar (% of normal) = 100 x R / Rn

Here, V is capacity-weighted 100 m wind speed in m/s, Vn is its date-specific normal, R is capacity-weighted shortwave radiation in W/m2, and Rn is its date-specific normal. These are meteorological inputs, not observed electricity generation.

How Are Wind and Solar Weighted in the DRI?

Expected wind output, Ew = Cw x CFw(d)

Expected solar output, Es = Cs x CFs(d)

Solar weight = Es / (Ew + Es)

Wind weight = Ew / (Ew + Es)

DRI = (wind weight x wind % of normal) + (solar weight x solar % of normal)

Cw and Cs represent installed wind and solar capacity. CFw(d) and CFs(d) are their normal capacity factors for calendar date d. The weights total one. Seasonal weighting avoids giving solar and wind identical influence during periods when their expected contributions to German generation differ substantially.

The DRI is not a measured renewable-generation fraction or a direct power price forecast. Wind generation depends nonlinearly on wind speed, while production from both technologies also depends on operational availability, equipment characteristics, and curtailment. For example, a DRI of 40 does not mean that 40% of installed wind and solar capacity is generating electricity.

What Defines a Low or Severe Dunkelflaute in This Analysis?

The example compares the daily DRI with seasonally varying reference thresholds: T20(d), the 20th-percentile threshold, and T10(d), the 10th-percentile threshold. The analysis derives date-specific historical percentiles from observed DRI data over 2010 to 2026 and uses a centered 31-day window to smooth their seasonal variation.

A day below T10(d) is unusually low relative to that part of the year. In this example, sustained runs below T20 identify Dunkelflaute-type episodes; sustained runs below T10 represent more severe episodes. Event duration must always be stated. “Below the 10th-percentile threshold” does not mean that only 10% of installed renewable capacity is generating.

Definitions of Dunkelflaute vary. For example, the Bundesnetzagentur uses a generation-based definition in which combined wind and solar PV output remains continuously below 15% of installed capacity for at least 48 hours. That is different from the example meteorological DRI, whose T20 and T10 thresholds refer to the index’s seasonally varying historical percentiles. Their event counts and severity categories are not interchangeable.

How Can Ensemble Forecasts Assess Dunkelflaute Threshold Risk?

Calculate the DRI separately for each ensemble member and forecast-valid date. The share of members below T20 or T10 shows the raw ensemble fraction forecasting conditions below that threshold on that date:

Fraction below T20 = members with DRI < T20 / total members

Fraction below T10 = members with DRI < T10 / total members

A fraction of ensemble members is not necessarily a statistically calibrated event probability. For a three-day or five-day event, the calculation should count each member that remains below the chosen threshold on every day required by the event definition. A sequence of elevated daily fractions does not itself demonstrate a sustained event within individual ensemble trajectories.

How Often Does Dunkelflaute Occur in Germany?

In the example’s daily DRI record from January 1, 2010 to October 1, 2026, 44 runs lasted at least five consecutive days below T20, an average of about 2.6 runs annually over the analyzed period. Nine runs lasted at least five consecutive days below T10, an average of approximately one such episode every 1.9 years. These are descriptive historical averages, not regular recurrence intervals.

The following table retains the complete event-duration counts from the example analysis. Each row gives the number of distinct runs lasting at least the specified number of consecutive days. An event that lasts ten days is also included in the rows for shorter minimum durations.

Minimum consecutive days Runs below T20 Runs below T10 Years with T20 runs Years with T10 runs
1+ 719 511 100% 100%
2+ 344 210 100% 100%
3+ 171 78 100% 100%
4+ 89 28 100% 88%
5+ 44 9 94% 38%
6+ 23 3 75% 19%
7+ 13 2 50% 13%
8+ 8 1 38% 6%
9+ 6 1 31% 6%
10+ 4 1 19% 6%
11+ 2 0 13% 0%
12+ 1 0 6% 0%
13+ 0 0 0% 0%
14+ 0 0 0% 0%

Source: Example DRI historical analysis, January 1, 2010 to October 1, 2026. Share-of-years values use the 16 full calendar years from 2010 through 2025, while average event rates use approximately 16.75 years of available daily data.

How Long Have Severe Dunkelflaute Episodes Lasted?

The longest observed run below T10 lasted ten days, from December 8 to 17, 2022. The only other run lasting at least seven days below T10 occurred January 19 to 25, 2017. The longest run below T20 lasted twelve days, from April 26 to May 7, 2022. No run in this record lasted thirteen or more consecutive days below either threshold.

Eight of the nine runs lasting at least five days below T10 began between September and April. Since the thresholds vary with the season, low-index runs can occur outside winter as well. The historical 10-day maximum is not a physical limit or a prediction of maximum future duration.

How Did ECMWF Forecasts Indicate Dunkelflaute Risk in December 2025?

ECMWF forecasts for December 1 to 5, 2025, increasingly favored below-normal 100 m wind speeds over Germany, while the solar-radiation signal was more spatially mixed. The observed example DRI subsequently ran below T20 for three days, December 3 to 5.

ECMWF probability maps of 100 m wind speed and solar radiation across Europe, valid December 1 to 5, 2025, shown through seven forecast initializations.

Figure 1. ECMWF forecast evolution for December 1 to 5, 2025.

100 m wind speed (upper panel) and solar radiation (lower panel), initialized November 25 to December 1, 2025, at 00Z. Reference period: 2005 to 2024. WCS ECMWF subseasonal maps. The embedded GIF contains seven forecast frames; some document viewers display only the first frame.

The embedded animation shows successive 00Z ECMWF subseasonal forecast initializations from November 25 through December 1, 2025, for the business-week period of December 1 to 5, 2025, relative to the 2005 to 2024 reference climatology. Across successive initializations, below-normal 100 m wind-speed signals become more extensive over Germany and parts of central Europe. Solar-radiation conditions are not uniformly below normal throughout Germany, and these meteorological probability maps do not forecast an observed Dunkelflaute event directly.

The observed DRI fell below T20 on December 3, 4, and 5, 2025. December 3 and December 5 also fell below T10, but December 4 did not. It was therefore a three-day consecutive run below T20, not a three-day consecutive run below T10.

What Did the Archived Ensemble DRI Forecasts Show?

The separate example DRI forecast animation applies the index to archived 00Z ensemble forecasts from the Point-in-Time Weather Forecast API, initialized November 25 through December 2, 2025. Because the archive stores each forecast as it was issued, the animation shows what the models indicated before the event. Its model panels are labeled AIFS-ENS, ECMWF, and GEFS. The member trajectories, ensemble distributions, and reference thresholds allow meteorologists to examine how the expected timing and severity of low-index conditions changed as the event approached.

The animation should be evaluated by matching the forecast-valid dates of December 3 to 5 to each initialization and examining the individual ensemble members. A forecast ensemble mean falling below a daily threshold is not the same as a calibrated probability of a three-day event. The observed three-day T20 run provides a subsequent reference for interpreting the archived forecasts.

AIFS-ENS, ECMWF, and GEFS forecasts of German Dunkelflaute Risk Index showing ensemble members and 20th- and 10th-percentile reference thresholds.

Figure 2. Example DRI ensemble forecast evolution from November 25 to December 2, 2025.

Example German Power Market Dunkelflaute Risk Index calculated from AIFS-ENS, ECMWF, and GEFS ensemble forecasts in the Point-in-Time Weather Forecast API. The embedded GIF contains eight initialization frames. Threshold lines show T20 and T10, which are defined from historical DRI observations.

How Can Energy Meteorologists and Trading Desks Use Dunkelflaute Forecasts?

Energy meteorologists can evaluate WCS medium-range and subseasonal wind and solar forecast guidance alongside ensemble index trajectories, such as the example DRI calculated from Point-in-Time Weather Forecast API forecasts, to examine location, onset, duration, and uncertainty. Compare forecast runs for identical valid dates, distinguish a one-day threshold crossing from a sustained member-level event, and communicate alternative ensemble outcomes. Review physical wind and solar fields separately before translating any index signal into expected generation or residual load.

What Should Power Traders Monitor?

A power desk can integrate the forecast signal with expected wind and solar generation, hourly load, residual load, dispatchable plant availability, storage schedules, and cross-border flows. The trading implications vary by bidding zone and delivery hour. Weather-driven supply risk should not be equated with an inevitable price movement or trading outcome.

What Should Natural Gas Traders Monitor?

A natural gas desk can evaluate the potential incremental demand from gas-fired generation while separately monitoring temperature-related heating demand, storage levels and withdrawals, pipeline supplies, LNG sendout, and fuel-switching economics. A cold Dunkelflaute may create a different gas-demand profile than a mild low-wind episode, so temperature and renewable-generation forecasts should not be combined into a single undifferentiated market signal.

Start a World Climate Service free trial

What Are the Main Limitations of Dunkelflaute Forecasts?

A meteorological index does not incorporate every factor determining realized power generation, gas dispatch, or electricity prices. Equipment availability, curtailment, demand, transmission, import capacity, and fuel costs remain separate inputs. Forecast uncertainty changes with lead time. Raw ensemble-member fractions are not necessarily calibrated event probabilities, and the archived forecasts shown here do not constitute a published forecast-skill assessment.

Historical event counts depend on the geographic aggregation, index construction, threshold, reference period, and required duration. The example DRI event frequencies must therefore be interpreted under the stated method rather than compared directly with studies using generation-based event definitions.

Frequently Asked Questions About Dunkelflaute

Does Every Dunkelflaute Definition Use the Same Threshold?

No. The example DRI in this article uses seasonally varying meteorological percentiles and a specified number of consecutive days. The Bundesnetzagentur uses a separate generation-based definition: combined wind and solar PV output below 15% of installed capacity for at least 48 hours. Frequencies under these definitions cannot be compared directly.

Can Dunkelflaute Occur Outside Winter?

Yes. Low wind and solar conditions relative to the seasonal normal can occur in other seasons. Their effects on total generation and demand may differ because daylight duration, installed capacity, and load conditions change through the year.

Is Low Wind Speed Alone Enough to Identify Dunkelflaute?

No. An assessment also requires solar radiation or generation conditions and a defined duration. A low-wind forecast alone does not establish that both renewable sources will be suppressed over the same period.

Can Dunkelflaute Be Forecast More Than One Week Ahead?

Numerical forecast models can indicate favorable conditions for low wind and solar generation at medium-range and longer lead times. The usefulness of that signal depends on lead time, geographic scale, event definition, and forecast verification. Forecasts should express uncertainty rather than assign certainty to a sustained event.

Does a DRI Value of 40 Mean 40% of Normal Renewable Generation?

No. The example DRI combines normalized meteorological variables using seasonal weights. It is not a direct measurement of renewable generation, installed capacity utilization, or electricity market prices.

Sources and Methodology

For additional WCS weather forecast analysis and historical context, request a free trial of World Climate Service.

World Climate Service trial
https://info.prescientweather.com/world-climate-service-free-trial

Recent Articles